• Skip to main content
  • Skip to secondary menu
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

Cleveland Daily

Cleveland Sports News, Rumors & Highlights

  • Home
  • Guardians News
  • Cavs News
  • Browns News
  • Newsletter
  • Contact
  • About

Should Baker Mayfield Be Considered A Bust?

By Spencer Richardson May 3, 2022

Baker Mayfield #6 of the Cleveland Browns lays on the field after a play in the second half against the Detroit Lions at FirstEnergy Stadium on November 21, 2021 in Cleveland, Ohio.
(Photo by Jason Miller/Getty Images)

 

On Tuesday morning, ​​ESPN’s Keyshawn Johnson, Jay Williams and Max Kellerman floated the “b-word” by former Cleveland Browns quarterback Baker Mayfield’s name.

Not “bad.”

Not “boisterous.”

Bust.

Johnson, Williams, and Kellerman, the hosts of the morning radio show “Keyshawn, JWill and Max,” seemed mixed.

Johnson labeled Baker’s NFL career a “disappointment,” drawing a line between that and “bust.”

Williams was also more upbeat in his characterization:

“Baker got the Browns to their first playoffs in a long time. Regardless of whether you want to say it was primarily based on their run game, he made plays down the stretch to get them there.”

Max Kellerman, who once co-hosted ESPN’s “First Take,” was the grimmest of the three:

“It is fair to say if you’re selected first or second overall pick, it’s a great accomplishment to get to the highest league in the world. But that’s a bust. By the standards of one of the top picks in the draft, bust is a completely legitimate word to use.”

In his short career, Mayfield did manage to lead the Browns to an 11-5 record and playoff appearance.

Every other year, though?

Mayfield’s ceiling seems to be six wins.

He managed only six wins in 2018, 2019, and 2021.

In those three seasons, he threw double-digit picks and his QBR ranged from a high of 54.4 (2019) to 35.1 (2021).

But until a disappointing 2021 season, Mayfield had shown general improvement, giving up eight picks against 26 TDs and earning a 65.6 QBR.

It’s also worth remembering that 2021-22 season was maligned by injury.

Another parroted myth about Baker Mayfield: he needs everything to be perfect around him.

In ‘20, he went 11-5 w/a playoff win w/no WR1 (OBJ), w/the 17th ranked D & a team ravaged by COVID in the playoffs w/no head coach & an OL Baker met in the locker room in PIT. #Browns https://t.co/dDLmSe8Afc

— Ed Greenberger (@EdGreenberger) April 27, 2022

Which Metric?

Going off of Kellerman’s metric – “one of the top picks” – perhaps Mayfield’s career isn’t what the Browns hoped it would develop into.

Though, to Mayfield’s credit, going No. 1 overall isn’t a surefire way to the Hall of Fame.

It comes with great expectations, but personnel, injury, and staffing also play important roles.

How does Mayfield stack up against other top picks?

Between 2014 and 2018, the No. 1 picks were, in order: Jadaveon Clowney, Jameis Winston, Jared Goff, Myles Garrett, and Mayfield.

Compared to those players, Mayfield is probably average.

Garrett is the obvious best in that field, and Mayfield might not have reached a Super Bowl like Goff, but generally, of the QBs in that bunch, one could argue Mayfield is the best (or at least most consistent).

hot take , I don’t think the Browns will ever regret moving on from Baker Mayfield BUT I think a good amount of teams will regret not trading minimal assets for him.

— Quincy Carrier (@Kwen_C) April 30, 2022

Against the Field

What if we look at Mayfield’s career by the other QBs taken in 2018?

It was expected to be a major QB draft, a major departure from the 2022 draft that concluded this past weekend.

Five QBs went in the first round in 2018: Mayfield, Sam Darnold, Josh Allen, Josh Rosen, and Lamar Jackson.

In that field, Mayfield is…smack average.

Jackson won Most Valuable Player honors his second season; Allen looks to be a fixture of the league for years to come, leading the Buffalo Bills to regular season and postseason success.

Darnold, for his part, could be Mayfield’s future teammate, having washed up for the Jets and failing to do much better in Carolina.

Rosen lasted a season in Arizona, had a cup of coffee in Miami, and even less than that in a few other spots across the league.

Presumably, he’s dusting off that UCLA resume for a job in some front office pretty soon (that is to say, his days of being an NFL player are probably over).

That leaves Mayfield, who hasn’t yet reached Jackson or Allen’s level, but has already far surpassed Rosen and Darnold as a quality contributor.

Does that make Mayfield a bust?

Probably not.

But that doesn’t mean his career hasn’t been disappointing.

    Get ALL the latest Cleveland sports news straight to your inbox! Subscribe to the Cleveland daily newsletter here!    

Filed Under: Cleveland Browns Rumors And News Tagged With: cleveland browns

Reader Interactions

Follow Cleveland Daily!

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

More Cleveland Browns News

Deshaun Watson #4 of the Cleveland Browns runs a drill during Cleveland Browns training camp at CrossCountry Mortgage Campus on July 30, 2022 in Berea, Ohio.

NFL World Reacts To Deshaun Watson Suspension Settlement

6 months ago

A Cleveland Browns helmet lays in the end zone before the game against the Baltimore Ravens at FirstEnergy Stadium on September 21, 2014 in Cleveland, Ohio. The Ravens defeat the Browns 23-21.

3 Browns Make The NFL's Initial Top-100 Release

6 months ago

The helmet of Damarious Randall #23 of the Cleveland Browns is shown before the Browns and Baltimore Ravens game at M&T Bank Stadium on September 29, 2019 in Baltimore, Maryland.

Browns O-Line Rocked By Another Season-Ending Injury

6 months ago

Deshaun Watson #4 of the Cleveland Browns looks to throw against the Jacksonville Jaguars during a football game at TIAA Bank Field on August 12, 2022 in Jacksonville, Florida.

Browns In Danger Of “Falling Behind” After Watson Trade?

6 months ago

Jerome Ford #34 of the Cleveland Browns scores against the Jacksonville Jaguars during a football game at TIAA Bank Field on August 12, 2022 in Jacksonville, Florida.

What To Expect From Jerome Ford This Season

6 months ago

Deshaun Watson #4 of the Cleveland Browns fumbles a snap against the Jacksonville Jaguars during a football game at TIAA Bank Field on August 12, 2022 in Jacksonville, Florida.

What's Next After Browns Center Nick Harris' Knee Injury?

6 months ago

The helmet of Damarious Randall #23 of the Cleveland Browns is shown before the Browns and Baltimore Ravens game at M&T Bank Stadium on September 29, 2019 in Baltimore, Maryland.

What To Watch For In Browns Preseason Opener Against Jaguars

6 months ago

A Cleveland Browns helmet lays in the end zone before the game against the Baltimore Ravens at FirstEnergy Stadium on September 21, 2014 in Cleveland, Ohio. The Ravens defeat the Browns 23-21.

2 Free Agent Targets After Jakeem Grant Injury

6 months ago

Kareem Hunt #27 of the Cleveland Browns runs a drill during Cleveland Browns training camp at CrossCountry Mortgage Campus on July 27, 2022 in Berea, Ohio.

Fans React To Kareem Hunt Holdout Report

6 months ago

A Cleveland Browns helmet lays in the end zone before the game against the Baltimore Ravens at FirstEnergy Stadium on September 21, 2014 in Cleveland, Ohio. The Ravens defeat the Browns 23-21.

David Bell Heads To Camp After Clearing PUP List

6 months ago

nfl field goal post

2 Things To Know About Peter C. Harvey

6 months ago

Condoleezza Rice, former Secretary of State and member of Augusta National, watches play on the 18th green during the final round of the Masters at Augusta National Golf Club on April 14, 2019 in Augusta, Georgia.

Report: Condoleezza Rice Could Be Tabbed With Watson Appeal

6 months ago

Jacoby Brissett #7 of the Cleveland Browns throws a pass during Cleveland Browns training camp at CrossCountry Mortgage Campus on July 27, 2022 in Berea, Ohio.

Best And Worst Case Scenarios For Jacoby Brissett

6 months ago

Deshaun Watson #4 of the Cleveland Browns runs a drill during Cleveland Browns training camp at CrossCountry Mortgage Campus on July 30, 2022 in Berea, Ohio.

Report: Deshaun Watson Plans To Sue NFL If League Appeals Suspension

6 months ago

What's Next After The Watson Suspension?

6 months ago

Taven Bryan Warming Up To Cleveland

6 months ago

Head coach Kevin Stefanski of the Cleveland Browns calls a play during Cleveland Browns training camp at CrossCountry Mortgage Campus on July 27, 2022 in Berea, Ohio.

Fans React To Browns' First Week Of Training Camp

6 months ago

Denzel Ward #21 of the Cleveland Browns covers Anthony Schwartz #10 in a drill during the Cleveland Browns OTAs at CrossCountry Mortgage Campus on May 25, 2022 in Berea, Ohio.

Browns Receiving Woes Continue With Schwartz Injury

6 months ago

Grant Delpit #22 of the Cleveland Browns reacts after a defensive penalty during the second quarter against the Arizona Cardinals at FirstEnergy Stadium on October 17, 2021 in Cleveland, Ohio.

Is A Big Year From Grant Delpit Coming?

6 months ago

A Cleveland Browns helmet lays in the end zone before the game against the Baltimore Ravens at FirstEnergy Stadium on September 21, 2014 in Cleveland, Ohio. The Ravens defeat the Browns 23-21.

Browns A Top-10 Team According To PFF

6 months ago

Anthony Schwartz #10 of the Cleveland Browns runs with the ball against the New England Patriots during the first quarter at Gillette Stadium on November 14, 2021 in Foxborough, Massachusetts.

Anthony Schwartz: Unfair To Take "All That Blame" For Mayfield's Injury

6 months ago

D'Ernest Johnson #30 of the Cleveland Browns carries the ball in the first half of the game against the Las Vegas Raiders at FirstEnergy Stadium on December 20, 2021 in Cleveland, Ohio.

Is D'Ernest Johnson On The Trade Block?

7 months ago

Cleveland Browns helmet rests on the field prior to the game against the Philadelphia Eagles at Lincoln Financial Field on September 11, 2016 in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. The Eagles defeated the Browns 29-10.

3 Browns Land In PFF's Top-50 List

7 months ago

Browns-bags-training-camp-1024x683

What David Bell's PUP Status Means For The Browns

7 months ago

Primary Sidebar

Search Cleveland Daily

Follow Cleveland Daily!

Footer

Privacy Policy

Terms And Conditions

Contact Us

Copyright © 2023 ALL RIGHTS RESERVED - ClevelandDaily.com is not affiliated with the Cleveland Indians or Major League Baseball.